We tasted dozens of spirits at ADI 2025 — everything from boundary-pushing experimental whiskey to botanical gin that smelled like a greenhouse on payday. But then, somewhere between conversations, panels, and “Wait, did we already try this one?” moments, we found ourselves talking with Stephen from Evolve Distilling … and then this bottle.

Evolve Distilling’s Caribbean Dark Rum.

It didn’t just catch our attention — it pinned us to the mat and demanded a proper review.

We swirled the glass. Deep, amber waves with golden maple highlights.
We nosed it.
And immediately realized:
This rum wasn’t here to participate. It was here to dominate.

The first aroma rolled in with a confidence you only see from Double Gold winners — and for good reason. This rum took Double Gold and Best in Class at ADI 2024, and honestly, after one sip, we understood exactly why.

It was rich.
It was layered.
It was unapologetically itself.

And we couldn’t wait to get back and write about it.

This is a rum built on craft, not shortcuts. The process alone tells you everything: a Caribbean white rum base aged eight months in an American white oak barrel previously used for both maple syrup and bourbon.

That barrel is doing the Lord’s work.

Molasses:
Not just a note — a statement. Deep, dark, sticky richness.

Maple:
Soft, warm sweetness from the barrel. Dessert-adjacent without being sugary.

Tropical fruit:
Banana, a hint of pineapple, subtle mango. Rum DNA shining through.

Vanilla & bourbon spice:
A reminder of the bourbon backbone baked into the wood.

Brown sugar & caramel:
Round, sweet, and warm — a slow-moving wave across the palate.

Finish:
Smooth, warm, elegant… and surprisingly long for a rum at this price point.

If you’re a fan of big, bold, personality-driven spirits, this bottle checks every box.

Neat:
Silky, rich, layered — where the maple-bourbon barrel influence shines brightest.

On ice:
Coaxes out more brown sugar and caramel sweetness with a velvety finish.

In cocktails:
Just… wow. Add this to a Mai Tai, Rum Old Fashioned, or a Jungle Bird and watch the drink evolve (yes, pun fully intended).

This is a rum that demands a good glass and a moment of appreciation.

Some spirits feel like they're trying to please everyone.
This one?
It knows exactly who it is and makes zero apologies.

Evolve Caribbean Dark Rum stands out because:

• It uses barrel finishing intelligently, not gimmicky
• It balances tropical rum character with bourbon-born richness
• It’s award-winning for a reason
• It delivers more depth than many rums twice the age
• It impressed us instantly — and that doesn’t happen often
   

It’s the kind of bottle you remember long after the tasting room lights turn off.

Pour this when:

• You want a rum with presence
• You’re introducing someone to what U.S. craft rum can achieve
• You want your Dark ‘n Stormy to be a problem
• Your Old Fashioned needs a tropical-maple twist
• You want something worthy of sharing with friends who appreciate serious craftsmanship
   

Try mixing it with:

• Fresh lime
• Spiced bitters
• Cold brew
• Coconut
• Ginger
• Orgeat
   

But don’t be surprised if you enjoy it neat more than anything else.

The fun part?
Tasting is personal — and this rum will hit everyone’s palate differently.

That’s why The Bar Book exists.

Use our Flavor Fingerprint™ to see exactly how Evolve Distilling Caribbean Dark Rum matches your palate, your preferences, your cocktail style, and what you’ve enjoyed before.

On The Bar Book, you can:

✔ Explore the bottle
✔ See its flavor map
✔ Compare drinker impressions
✔ Read real reviews
✔ Match similar rums
✔ Build your own rum-lover profile

👉 Check it out on The Bar Book

This Evolve Caribbean Dark Rum review highlights a craft rum with real personality — rich molasses, tropical depth, maple warmth, and bourbon-kissed spice born from its unique maple syrup/bourbon barrel aging. Award-winning, full-bodied, and smooth, it’s a must-try for anyone exploring the evolving world of craft distilleries and premium sipping rums.

Discover how this bottle fits your taste using The Bar Book — the flavor-matching app known as the Vivino for spirits and the Spotify for alcohol. Personalized recommendations, drink matching, and full tasting notes are waiting for you.

Where Flavor Meets Story.
Tasted and Reviewed by The Bar Book Team.
https://thebarbook.app

If you would like us to spotlight your brand for FREE, send us an email — we’ll gladly add your bottle to our lineup of stories, tastings, and flavor deep dives.